Blogging


Turning Blog Comments Off - a Short Case Study by @mattgemmell

Matt Gemmell says,

"One month after switching comments off, I'm a happier blogger and writer."

Short story shorter, about a month ago Matt turned off comments on his popular blog.  His argument was basically that blog comments serve a very small number of visitors (less than 1% in his opinion) and cost much more in time and angst than they're worth.  The people who do comment are either spammers or motivated by disagreement and are never in their best frame of mind.  Also, the anonymity of blog comments can bring out the worst in people.

There are enough alternatives to on-site comments, that this move was feasible to him.  People can comment on Twitter, through their own blog posts (like I'm doing here, I suppose) and via email.

His update today, here it is again, validates and affirms his decision with little to no downside, and lots of benefits such as faster loading sites, more distributed content being created on other blogs and twitter, no moderation of spam, and whiter whites.

There are many times that I've also questioned the value and benefits of blog comments.  They tend to be a flash in the pan, and depending on the platform the blog is hosted on, it can be difficult to keep tabs on posts that you've commented on in various places.

But there are also some blogs that are a pleasure to read, due in no small part to the comments.

So while this move may not be for everyone, it's one that some bloggers can certainly afford to try, and perhaps they'll come out better for it.

 

jangro

Explore more...