Affiliate Links in Twitter, Amazon Says No

posted by jangro on (2 years, 10 months ago)

We've been around the block a time or two about whether twitter is an appropriate place to post affiliate links.

Most of the affiliate networks prohibit the posting of affiliate links in forums, blog comments, etc.; in other words, you cannot post (read spam) affiliate links on sites that you do not own.

As we discussed the topic of affiliate links in twitter, this issue occurred to me. Since people don't "own" twitter, does that fall into the above categories. In my mind, it doesn't as I consider twitter a blogging platform that's no different from blogger or other hosted blogging solutions in this context. I even asked someone from the network quality team at one of the networks and they agreed with me on that.

However, surprisingly enough, Amazon differs on this. Amazon Associate, Joshua Odmark reported on Search Engine Journal that Amazon slashed his commissions from amazon links that he posted on his Twitter and Facebook accounts. Why? They cited their terms that links must be posted on "Your Site".

It seems that they take the "Your Site" distinction pretty seriously.

What's not entirely clear to me is whether it's that they object to Twitter and Facebook specifically, or just that these links were not posted on the site that was on the application.

And would they accept these sites in an application? I guess this would also exclude sending someone a referral link in email? That's not "Your Site" either.

Joshua hasn't been able get any sort of explanation out of Amazon. I'll be keeping an eye on this one.


Comments & Reactions

  • jangro saved this to Affiliate Marketing 2 years, 10 months ago
  • Posted by If You Twitter Affiliate Links - Amazon Won’t Pay - 5 Star Affiliate Blogs 2 years, 10 months ago

    [...] I picked up the story via Jangro, so head over and read what he has to say as well. Affiliate Links in Twitter, Amazon Says No [...]

  • Posted by Amazon laat Delicious Libary uit de App Store halen > Nieuws > iPhoneclub.nl 2 years, 10 months ago

    [...] een soortgelijk probleem in het nieuws: ze betalen niet langer een vergoeding uit wanneer mensen via Twitter bepaalde Amazon-producten aanprijzen. tweetmemeurl = '
    http://www.iphoneclub.nl/31313/31313/';tweetmeme
    source = [...]

  • Posted by Julia 2 years, 10 months ago

    Hi Scott,

    Thanks a lot for the article - here's our view of Amazon's reasons for not allowing affiliate links on Twitter/Facebook. I think there's a conversation potential there because of a few conflicting ideas, so please let us know your view:


    http://www.lakestarmedia.com/blog/post/2009/07/08/Is-Amazon-Correct-in-Not-Counting-Affiliate-Links-From-Twitter-and-Facebook.aspx

    Thanks, Julia

    Posted by Scott Jangro 2 years, 10 months ago

    Hi Julia.

    I disagree completely with your argument that there's no room for intellectual property or unique content in a 140 character tweet. In fact I disagree with pretty much everything you wrote.

    I can express my unique opinion on an Amazon product in 140 characters just fine.

    Posted by Julia 2 years, 10 months ago

    Thanks for your opinion and article, Scott :)

  • Posted by Shawn Collins 2 years, 10 months ago

    I am curious where the line in the sand is with this policy - if I have a blog at wordpress.com or tumblr.com, it's my site... my blog.

    I submitted a question to Amazon to ask this question.

    Posted by Scott Jangro 2 years, 10 months ago

    Good question Shawn.

    Seems to me that if they're going to play the "not 'your site', aka the site on the approved application" card, then it's all or nothing.

    Otherwise, this whole thing is totally arbitrary which is no way to do business.

  • Posted by Stephanie Lichtenstein 2 years, 10 months ago

    I don't like that they use "your site." It is so vague that they could come back and use it in any way that they want.

  • Posted by Make Money Online with Twitter! | The Real Tim Jones 2 years, 10 months ago

    [...] as I learned from Scott Jangro, Joshua Odmark had affiliate commissions revoked by Amazon for using Amazon Associate links [...]

  • Posted by Mark Olsen 2 years, 10 months ago

    I have posted affiliate links in Twitter and will continue to do so. In my view as long as your links are somehow related to your tweets - your friends - or anything real they are fine. What I don't agree with is the out-right fraud - such as the many fake tweets that have been posted in conjunction with the Iran Problems #iranelection - such as "Check out these new videos of Iran violence - (link)" when you click to see the video you instead go to an Obama zip/email sumbit landing page. Zac Johnson has a similar post today here -
    http://zacjohnson.com/dirty-college-girls-take-over-twitter/ My view - real affiliate links from real people - good - the rest .....?

  • Posted by Heart Association Diet 2 years, 10 months ago

    Just my own feling and $.02 - Twitter is doomed for this type of marketing. The best you should look for re:Twitter is communicating with customers, email lists, etc.

    Harold

  • Posted by Bisnis Internet 2 years, 10 months ago

    Yes, now amazon will not pay affiliate earning through twitter.

    Posted by Shawn Collins 2 years, 10 months ago

    Did you ask Amazon about it yourself?

  • Posted by Becoming Amazon affiliate without a website? - Thirty Day Challenge Forums 2 years, 10 months ago

    [...] are a number of affiliates that are having problem with payment. See the following two articles: Affiliate Links in Twitter, Amazon Says No | Jangro.com No Precedence For Social Media - Amazon Hangs Us Out To Dry cheers __________________ Imrat [...]

  • Posted by Sökmotoroptimering 2 years, 10 months ago

    I don’t like that they use “your site.” It is so vague that they could come back and use it in any way that they want.

  • Posted by Pete Williams 2 years, 10 months ago

    Well I spoke to Amazon UK about this, and they don't seem to have a problem with it:

    "Dear Associate,

    Thank you for writing to the Amazon.co.uk Associates Program.

    In relation to your e-mail below, links posted on Twitter do earn commission. Any items ordered via your links will register to your Associate account and you will earn referral fees according to the Performance Fee Plan which you are currently enrolled in."

    Pete

  • Posted by gmpoint 2 years, 10 months ago

    oh,this is really bad,i was planning to use twitter for business but it seems that it ill not work,but anywhy it still a very good way to advertise

  • Posted by Joe Cigarettes 2 years, 10 months ago

    This is just another case of the "Golden Rule." That is, He Who Has The Gold, Makes The Rules. Amazon has the gold...they make the rules. Whether it might seem arbitrary on their part or not, they get to decide whether or not any particular site is the property of any particular individual, for the purposes of affiliate advertising. It might seem unfair, but it seems to be the present reality of things.

  • Posted by talia 2 years, 10 months ago

    Huh, I never would have thought they would do that. It seems kinda dumb on Amazon's part, I mean after all, if it's driving targeted traffic their way what is their problem. I know if something got my jewelry blog making more money I wouldn't penalize whoever was doing it. Weird and shortsighted I would think.

  • Posted by Sportsbook Software 2 years, 10 months ago

    I think posting affiliate links on twitter should be allowed. I think you're exactly right when you say it's a form of blogging. It's your own individual page of twitter and you've got your own audience.

    Amazon is an idiot.

  • Posted by haber 2 years, 9 months ago

    I don’t like that they use “your site.” It is so vague that they could come back and use it in any way that they want.

  • Posted by thom 2 years, 9 months ago

    I actually dislike to use my tweety for comercial purpose. So, I agree with amazon in this case.

  • Posted by Microsoft Guy 2 years, 9 months ago

    Yes no more spammy followers!

  • Posted by Roger 2 years, 9 months ago

    I don't know why companies like Amazon don't like direct linking to their products, if it sells why not they pay us commission when somenone actually buy something and not pay per click ...

    http://www.pedipawstrimmer.info/" rel="nofollow">Roger

  • Posted by Brent Patton 2 years, 9 months ago

    I hate spammers anyways nice article thanks for sharing

  • Posted by Mary Winston 2 years, 9 months ago

    There're a good and bad point from this Amazon agreement. IMHO, If they create an affiliate program, that means that they're looking for more sales which is generate more income for them. Why they just don't let the affiliate persons do their job and they handle the rest. Advertiser will get more sales, affiliate person will generate more income, both of us made profit, that's a win win solution.

    The good point is, as an advertiser, vendor, they get more specific targetted buyers and eliminate a lot of any fakes, spam visitors

  • Posted by Henrik B 2 years, 9 months ago

    That sure is a grey line for sure, it seems ridiculous, that Amazon won’t let us make money for them, unless it’s “our site”….

  • Posted by PC Repair 2 years, 9 months ago

    I am sorry but I must agreed with Amazon.  If we were allowed to post affiliate links anywhere, it would be just like spaming and anyone will do start doing it.  That is way you have to own a website or blog, is like a recommendation from your site and even more thrustful.  Personally I wouldn't like to have affiliate links on my sites that I didin't approved.

  • Posted by Is Amazon Correct in Not Counting Affiliate Links From Twitter and Facebook? | Lakestar Media 2 years, 9 months ago

    [...] There is a bit of kerfuffle over Amazon Associates program slashing an advertiser’s revenue from affiliate links posted on Twitter and Facebook. You can read the full story here. [...]

  • Posted by Mike Stanislaus 2 years, 8 months ago

    It's better practice to bring people to your landing page anyway. It's not a big deal to make a blogpost and then let people go from there.

  • Posted by Affiliates: New Social Media Marketing Guide – Amazon Sets Record Straight - 5 Star Affiliate Blogs 2 years, 6 months ago

    [...] Odmark. No Precedence For Social Media – Amazon Hangs Us Out To Dry. Jangro blogged it: Affiliate Links in Twitter, Amazon Says No And so did I: If You Twitter Affiliate Links – Amazon Won’t [...]

  • Posted by Amazon Affiliate Links On Twitter: To Tweet Or Not To Tweet | The Real Tim Jones 2 years, 6 months ago

    [...] feed or for more frequent, informal updates, you can follow me on Twitter. Thanks for visiting!So, back in July, Amazon says no affiliate links to be used on [...]

  • Posted by nassy 2 years, 6 months ago

    http://my-buddiez.com/classifieds/gmoneypro' rel="nofollow">I agree with that !

  • Posted by nassy 2 years, 6 months ago

    http://my-buddiez.com/classifieds/gmoneypro' rel="nofollow">I agree with that !

  • Posted by Hakan 2 years, 4 months ago

    :):)

  • Posted by beginningaffiliatemarketing 2 years, 2 months ago

    Yeah I agree with Amazon, it's just a spam prevention method, affiliate marketers should have their own websites anyways.

  • Posted by spormix 2 years ago

    ? hate spams, thanks for sharing...

  • Posted by spormix 2 years ago

    Thanks for sharing, it's very helpfull

  • Posted by spormix 2 years ago

    Thans for sharing..

    http://www.spormix.com" title="spo haberleri" target="_blank" rel="nofollow">spor

  • Posted by Soham@stretch marks 1 year, 11 months ago

    Till we get a detailed definition of "your site" from Amazon it would seem strange to me. Twitter should worry about spam prevention not Amazon.... now that is my logic.

  • Eiddaa_com

    Posted by Eiddaa_com 4 months, 1 week ago


Leave a comment


Comment via Facebook

Listed Under

Reactions

Tags